• Authors
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact us
  • Legal
  • Technology
  • News
  • Careers
  • Conferences
  • Events
No Result
View All Result
  • Legal
  • Technology
  • News
  • Careers
  • Conferences
  • Events
No Result
View All Result
Legaltech
No Result
View All Result

English High Court judgment paved the way for crypto-litigation

by Christopher Lytras
05/05/2020
Reading Time: 5 mins read
English High Court judgment paved the way for crypto-litigation
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on Llinkedin

English High Court judgment paved the way for crypto-litigation

Case

In the recent case of AA v Persons Unknown[1] the English High Court concluded that cryptoassets, in this case Bitcoin, can be treated as “property” and can therefore be the subject of a proprietary injunction.

Facts

The Insurer sought to recover the Bitcoin by issuing various proprietary claims (restitution and/or as constructive trustees) in respect of money which had been demanded from its customer as a ransom and paid in Bitcoin. The customer’s computer systems had been hacked and encrypted. It received ransom demands from persons unknown, the 1st defendant. The insurer agreed to pay US $950,000 in Bitcoin and the system was decrypted. The money was transferred into a Bitcoin account controlled by persons unknown, 2nd defendant, and linked to a Bitcoin exchange operated by the 3rd and 4th defendants.

The insurer brought ex-parte applications seeking, amongst other things, proprietary injunctions to restrict the defendants’ ability to use and/or transfer the Bitcoin, given the high likelihood that the Bitcoin would be dissipated before a final judgment was issue.

In considering whether the insurer was entitled to such proprietary injunction, the court had to consider whether a cryptoasset can constitute property.

Cryptoassets as Property

Bryan J, in answering the pivotal question whether or not cryptoassets are property, he accepted that the question was of peculiar nature since, under the traditional view enunciated in the case Colonial Bank v Whinney[2] property can have only two forms, either:

(1) ‘thing in possession’ (ie, tangible assets) or

(2) ‘thing in action’ (eg, debt or contractual rights).

Binance Referral Link Binance Referral Link
ADVERTISEMENT

Anything else, between the two, is no tertium quid and not recognizable under the law.

Cryptoassets are neither a ‘thing in possession’, because they are virtual and cannot be possessed or a ‘thing in action’, because they do not embody any right capable of being enforced.

However, after considering the detail analysis of the legal statement of the UK jurisdictional Task Force on “Crypto-Assets and Smart Contracts” dated 11th November 2019 (“UKJT Legal Statement”) he concluded that while a cryptoasset might not be a ‘thing in action’ on the narrow definition of that term, that did not in itself mean that it cannot be treated as property.

Bryan J, in adopting the detail analysis of UKJT Legal Statement, he agreed that the Colonial Bank case should not be read as limiting the scope of things that can be property in law since common law has the ability to stretch traditional definitions to facilitate and adopt to new business practises.

He further noted that cryptoassets, such as Bitcoin, satisfy the criteria set out in Lord Wilberforce’s classic definition of property in National Provincial Bank v Ainsworth[3] since they are: (i) definable (ii) identifiable by third parties, (iii) capable in their nature of assumption by third parties, and (iv) have some degree of permanence.

Bryan J also refer to the judgment of the Singapore International Commercial Court in B2C2 Limited v Quoine PTC Limited[4], which followed the same approach on the issue.  It must be noted that in the Court of Appeal of Singapore[5] the issue of the nature of the cryptocurrencies was not concluded, even thought it was examined and discussed, the court stated that:

“There may be much to commend the view that cryptocurrencies should be capable of assimilation into the general concepts of property. There are, however, difficult questions as to the type of property that is involved. It is not necessary for us to come to a final position on this question in the present case”.[6]

Comment

The decision of Brian J clarifies the legal status of cryptoassets as property by providing a detail judicial reasoning. While the characteristics of cryptoassets can vary, the decision does indicates that the common law courts are likely to find that established, tradable cryptocurrencies can be treated as property.

Thereby paving a path of certainty and protection for victims of cyber-attacks and cryptocurrency investors in cases of misappropriation.

Cyprus courts

The Cyprus courts by virtue of section 29(1)(c) of the Courts of Justice Law 1960 (Courts of Justice Law), apply “the common law and the doctrines of equity save in so far as other provision has been or shall be made by any law”. In essence English case law and principles are extensively applied and provide valuable guidance to the Cyprus courts.

In view of the above it is highly arguable that the Cyprus courts will apply the dynamic principles of common law, to safeguard the interest of victims of cyber extortion who have paid ransoms in cryptocurrencies. In doing so the seminal judgment of Bryan J will be of an immense assistance.

Share this:

  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Pocket
Source: [1] [2019] EWHC 3556 (Comm) [2] [1885] 30 Ch.D 261 [3] [1965] 1 AC 1175 [4] [2019] SGHC (I) 03 [5] [2020] SGCA(I) 02 [6] Ibid. paragraph [144]
Tags: cryptolegallitigation

Christopher Lytras

Christopher Lytras read law at the University of Sussex, England and was awarded an LL.B. He also holds an LL.M. in Banking and Finance from the University of London. Christopher was admitted to the Cyprus Bar in 2016. He is an Advocate at Montanios & Montanios LLC. His practise covers a broad range of contesting issues with multijurisdictional element and with particular emphasis on civil & commercial fraud, corporate & shareholders’ disputes and maritime law. Christopher is currently pursuing the Advanced Diploma in International Taxation ('ADIT') qualification which is being awarded by the Chartered Institute of Taxation ('CIOT').

Related Posts

Non Fungible Token ,NFT, digital
Technology

NFTs: The Bedrock of the Virtual Economy

08/03/2022
Cryptocurrencies

Visa to Accept USDC in Its Payments Network

29/03/2021

Recommended.

Online Seminar-Marketing for Law Firms by Zygos Academy

Online Seminar-Marketing for Law Firms by Zygos Academy

15/05/2020
Βlockchain διαιτησία και «έξυπνα» συμβόλαια

Βlockchain διαιτησία και «έξυπνα» συμβόλαια

02/06/2020

Trending.

Crisis-Critical Intellectual Property: Findings from the COVID-19 Pandemic

Crisis-Critical Intellectual Property: Findings from the COVID-19 Pandemic

13/04/2020
The future of Maritime Industry and Global transportation

The future of Maritime Industry and Global transportation

03/05/2020
Τεχνητή νοημοσύνη: Ένα εργαλείο για τον δικηγόρο του σήμερα

Τεχνητή νοημοσύνη: Ένα εργαλείο για τον δικηγόρο του σήμερα

10/05/2020
Law & Technology: E-justice & Legal Technology

Law & Technology: E-justice & Legal Technology

16/01/2023
big-4-accounting

‘Big 4’ Accounting Giants accept their First Bitcoin Payment

25/03/2021
Legaltech

Legal for Techies - Tech for Lawyers

Follow Us

Recent News

Law & Technology: E-justice & Legal Technology

Law & Technology: E-justice & Legal Technology

16/01/2023
Non Fungible Token ,NFT, digital

NFTs: The Bedrock of the Virtual Economy

08/03/2022
  • Authors
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact us

© 2020 Legaltech

No Result
View All Result
  • Legaltech
  • Technology
    • Blockchain & DLT
    • Cryptocurrencies
    • Fintech
    • Startups
    • Software
    • Security
    • Hardware
  • Legal
    • ADR
    • E-Justice
    • EU Law
    • Gov. Announcements
    • Intellectual Property
    • Personal Data
    • Case summaries
  • News
  • Careers
  • Conferences
  • Events
  • Contact us

© 2020 Legaltech

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

Fill the forms bellow to register

*By registering into our website, you agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.
All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Fore more details visit our Privacy Policy and Cookie Policy